A Guide to Grocery and Convenience Stores of Upstate New York

Here is your quick lowdown on all the best places to grab groceries and other necessities.

Ideally, during your time in upstate NY and the Catskills you can buy most of your food at a farmers’ market and your drinks at a local brewery or winery. However, that’s not always realistic, particularly if you’re here for a long time. So here is a quick guide to where you can go easily to pack up on goods.

Before you venture out to any of these grocery stores or convenience stores be sure to check their hours and that they are open. This is the country, after all, you need to double-check things are open before you make that drive.

Grocery Stores

Pecks Market (Eldred, NY) 

This is our favorite grocery store in the area and is only about 15 minute drive. We love to buy local meat and produce from here when we can’t make it to the farmer’s market. This is our favorite traditional grocery store in the area.

Save A Lot (Port Jervis, NY)

This is the closest grocery store to Clearing Farm and is geared at value shoppers. It’s a nice place to stop if you’re in a pinch and need to dash in to find food at a cheap price.

ShopRite (Matamoras, PA)

A popular chain grocery store with everything you need, and only about 20 minutes away from the farm. This is a great grocery store to stop at if you’re coming in from New York City; perfectly along the way when you pull off the 84 highway from the city or Middletown. This one does not come up on GPS so you might need to enter the exact address: 111 Hulst Dr #711, Matamoras, PA 18336.

Convenience Stores

Barryville General (Barryville, NY)

A super cute, and super fun general store with all sorts of creative goods, fresh produce, and sandwiches. We love this place so much!

Hess Store (Port Jervis, NY)

This is our favorite convenience store in the area, mainly because of the authentic vibe inside the place and the incredible sandwiches they make here. It’s also the best place to go to grab eggs, milk, beer — or as a place to grab your own sandwich meat to make something later for yourself.

Pete’s Country Store (Glen Spey, NY)

Looking for a bag of ice? Beer? Some extra firewood? Maybe a bag of chips or some gum? Then Pete’s Country Store is your closest and best bet. They also have a CITGO gas station here if you need to fuel up.

Forestburgh General Store (Forestburgh, NY)

This super cute general store is as cute as it is practical. Decorated in a truly beautiful way, this general store has all the essentials and a bunch of amazing upstate souvenirs. The Forestburgh General Store also has gourmet sandwiches and coffee. Download the menu here and be sure to call ahead so you don’t have to wait for your food. This general store is about 15 minutes away from the farm.

Riteaid (Port Jervis, NY)

Just your typical Riteaid with everything you would expect from a Riteaid…